Animals: Chapters Nine, Ten and Eleven

WHEN SURGEONS OPERATE ON PEOPLE WHO DON’T NEED IT, HOW FAR WILL THEY GO TO PROTECT THE SECRET AND KEEP THE MONEY COMING IN?

Chapter Nine

November 9, 2024

He worked out in the hotel gym at seven-thirty, showered, and ate breakfast downstairs at Jean-Georges, methodically, the way he did everything in the mornings because it was then, in the mornings he had to be sharp. Surgery. Seeing 20 patients in clinic. There was no room for error.

Before he left for the meeting he stopped at the front desk and paid for another night. He had no plans for the evening, nothing arranged, and he liked the open feeling of a hotel room in the city with the night still undeclared. Standing in the lobby while he waited for the car the car service, he felt something he didn’t let himself name too directly, a loosening, a sense of the future taking a shape he could nearly see the outline of. He felt something else too, beneath it and less welcome, a twinge that was probably regret, the kind that arrives when you’re in a good mood and your guard is down and it finds the opening it’s been waiting for. The life he’d lived. The way he’d lived it, these past few years especially. He didn’t chase the feeling. Regret.

The car was ready.

550 Madison, the old Sony Building rose over the avenue with authority. Jack got out of the car, straightened his jacket, charcoal cashmere, no tie, the kind of weekend-casual that cost more than most people’s work clothes, and went in.

Larry was waiting at the tenth-floor elevator bank, the reception area carrying the emptiness of a professional floor given the weekend off, the desk unmanned, the place quiet. He was in a blazer and open collar, which for Larry was informal.

“How are you feeling?” Larry said, as they shook hands.

“Fine.” The word came clipped and final.

Larry looked at him a moment. “Jack. This is a conversation, not a deposition. She’s trying to close a file.”

“I know what it is.”

“Then let’s keep it that way.”

Jack’s jaw moved. He looked off toward the window. “I said I’m fine, Larry.”

Larry let it go. He’d made the point; making it again would cost more than it bought. Jack was dressed, he noted, as if the outfit had been chosen to communicate something. Jack always thought these things mattered. Here they almost certainly didn’t. But there were conversations worth having with Jack and conversations that weren’t, and this was firmly the second kind.

Karen came through the door, and the first thing Larry noticed was Jack’s face doing the thing it did very rarely, registering genuine surprise. She wasn’t what he’d expected. You could see it in the fraction of a second his expression took to recalibrate before he stood, a half-beat, barely there, the adjustment a man makes when the room doesn’t match the picture he’d been carrying of it. She was younger than the letter had suggested, blond, athletic, with a manner so warm and disarming it took a moment to notice the warmth was also a tool and she knew exactly how to use it. She shook Jack’s hand first, then Larry’s.

“Dr. Connor, thank you so much for making the time. I know a Saturday isn’t ideal.”

“Not a problem.” He’d found his register already, the professional warmth of a caring doctor. “I appreciate you being flexible.”

“Mr. McGuire. Good to put a face to the voice.”

“Likewise,” Larry said.

She led them down the hall, mentioning with a self-deprecating half-laugh that she didn’t usually work out of this office and hoped they could find the conference room without too much trouble. Larry asked if she was in Philadelphia mostly. Mostly, yes, Walnut Street, though she seemed to spend half her life in a car; she imagined they knew the feeling. The Turnpike, Larry said. Every evening. She laughed. Jack produced a brief cooperative smile. Three people walking down a hallway on a Saturday, everything completely fine.

The conference room was far larger than the meeting required, a table that could have seated sixteen, windows the full length of one wall, the whole thing done in the corporate neutral of spaces meant to convey calm and conveying expense instead. “I reserved it online,” Karen said, spreading her hands at the empty acreage of table. “I may have misjudged.”

Larry laughed. Even Jack almost smiled. “We can make it work,” Jack said.

They sat at the head of the table, three water bottles already set out, and in front of Karen’s chair a legal pad squared precisely to the table’s edge and three manila files stacked in a neat column. She uncapped her pen, laid it parallel to the pad, and looked at Jack with an expression that had settled into something direct and genuine. Not the hallway warmth. Something quieter and more serious, the face of a person about to do their actual job.

“Dr. Connor. Before anything else, I’m very sorry for your loss. I know this has been an extraordinarily difficult time, and I want you to know everything we’re doing is in service of resolving this as efficiently and respectfully as possible.” She held his eyes. “Some of what I ask may feel repetitive, or basic. I ask everyone the same questions, and I want you to have that context up front.”

“I appreciate that,” Jack said, with the practiced gravity of a physician who has delivered bad news and received it.

Karen started with the timeline. When had he last spoken to Ilana before she was found? That morning, Jack said, without hesitation. They’d spoken briefly. She’d mentioned she was going for a run after her clinic.

“And when you got the news, can you walk me through that? Who contacted you, what you were told?”

He walked her through it. The call from the sheriff’s office. The drive up. The identification. He said it with the composed, measured cadence of someone who has processed the loss enough to describe it without breaking, which was either genuine or a very good reproduction of genuine, and Larry found, as he had before, that he couldn’t tell the difference. Karen wrote after each answer, not at once but with a small delay that suggested absorbing rather than transcribing.

“I’m sorry,” she said when he finished. And seemed to mean it. “Let me ask about Ilana’s health. Was she under regular care for anything?”

“A thyroid condition. Longstanding. Well managed. She’d had it for years.”

“Any recent changes to her medications? Dosages?”

“Not that I knew of. Her internist would have the records.”

“And her general health otherwise, how did she seem in the months before?”

“Unremarkable. For a woman her age. She was healthy.” He paused. “She was careful about her health.”

Karen nodded and wrote.

“Did you notice any changes in her mood or behavior in the months before she died? Any unusual stress?”

Jack’s answers here came slightly fuller, slightly more careful. “Some stress,” he said. “Normal things. The kind anyone would have.” As he said it his thumb moved once, slowly, along the side of the water bottle. It was nothing. The kind of nothing visible only if you were watching for it, and Larry was watching for it, because he’d been watching Jack’s hands in difficult situation for over two decades, and Karen, he noticed, glanced at the hand and came back to Jack’s face without a flicker.

“Of course. Any significant financial stress you were aware of? Changes in spending?”

“No. We were comfortable. We’d always been careful.”

She asked about Maya, how she was managing. “As well as can be expected,” Jack said, in the tone of someone closing a subject. Karen heard it, nodded, let it close, and wrote something Larry couldn’t read from where he sat.

It was all normal, Larry thought. Jack was measured, sympathetic, exactly the widower the situation called for. He let himself relax a little.

Then Karen shifted in her chair.

A small movement. She changed the angle of her body by a few degrees, looked at Jack with the same pleasant expression, and said she had a few questions about the move to New Jersey, if that was all right. It was relevant, she explained, because the old policies had been tied to the group and cashed out when they left, so the policy in question, while not technically new, was only four years old. She smiled, the sympathetic smile, the one that had been doing a great deal of work all morning. “Can you tell me a bit about what prompted the decision to leave the White Plains practice?”

Jack shifted. It was small. The kind of movement that might have looked, to someone who didn’t know him, like a man adjusting his posture. Larry knew better. He’d seen Jack’s body do this exact thing twice in twenty years, both times right before a situation that had needed significant management. He said nothing.

Jack’s answer came out smoothly. Differences of opinion about business direction. Better opportunities elsewhere. The group had run its course. He said it in the same way he’d used for everything else, the words practiced and even, and Larry placed it suddenly. It was the same answer, in almost exactly the same words, Jack had given him years ago when Larry had asked what really happened at White Plains Surgery Centers. Not the same account. The same answer. Smooth where an account is textured, general where an account is specific, worn by repetition into something with no edges left.

“I’m sorry it didn’t work out,” Karen said. “A move like that, with a teenager, that must have been hard.”

“It was an adjustment. But we both had portable careers. That made it easier.” Maya, Larry knew, had been away at boarding school by then; the move had cost her nothing. Jack didn’t volunteer it.

“I’m glad,” she said. And then, in the same light conversational tone, no change in pace or tenor, as if it were merely the next thing on the list and not the thing she’d been building toward for the better part of an hour: “Your answer is actually consistent with what Dr. Cope and Dr. Singer described when I spoke with them.”

The room changed.

It didn’t change visibly or audibly, not in any way a recording device would have caught. It changed the way pressure changes, in the space between one breath and the next, in the quality of the silence before Jack spoke. Larry felt it in his chest. He watched Jack’s face and saw the thing he’d known, at some level, since they walked in, was going to happen. The jaw. The faint color at the collar. The eyes going from measured to something less managed.

“What?” The word came out wrong. Too sharp, too fast, a man who’d been controlled for an hour and just lost the thread of it. “You spoke to my old partners?”

Karen held his eyes. “Yes, Dr. Connor.”

Two words. Completely flat. Completely level. Delivered with the finality of a thing that has already happened and is not up for revision. Larry looked at her and felt the floor tilt slightly. The woman who’d walked out to meet them, pleasant, disarming, the kind of face you’d be comfortable seeing anywhere, had become, with no visible transition, something a good deal more focused. The warmth was still technically there, the way a room holds heat after the fire goes out. But her eyes had changed. They had the look of an attention that had been present all along and had simply stopped pretending otherwise.

A leopard, Larry thought, that had been sitting very still for a very long time.

The moment stretched. Then she smiled, and the smile was genuine enough, or near enough that the difference was academic. “It’s entirely standard, Dr. Connor. On a claim this size I need the full professional and financial context and speaking with former colleagues is part of that. I should have mentioned it earlier, and I apologize for the surprise.” She said it pleasantly. She said it as if explaining it were a courtesy to him. “And frankly, Dr. Cope and Dr. Singer both spoke very well of you and Ilana. I hope that’s some comfort.”

Jack’s breath went out through his nose. Controlled. Just. “I understand. I just wasn’t aware that was part of the process.” The words came out at a reasonable temperature. It had cost him to get them there, and it showed, faintly, at the edges.

Jack nodded. The color kept subsiding. Larry watched him find his footing and felt the room begin, cautiously, to stabilize.

Then Karen said, in the same easy fashion, that she’d also noticed Steven Gula had left the group just before it dissolved. She’d met with him, she said. She paused as if assembling a thought. “He seems to have landed a little less easily than the others. He’s a professor now. History, of all things. Quite a change.” She tilted her head slightly. “A little guarded, I suppose. Though some people find the whole process uncomfortable. Seems like things worked out better for some of you than for others.”

What moved in Jack’s face this time wasn’t the earlier thing. The earlier reaction had been anger, familiar, recognizable, the thing Larry had spent twenty years managing. This came from below anger, from somewhere more primitive and more reflexive, and it didn’t have the feel of a thing that could be managed, because it hadn’t been built with management in mind.

“What the hell are you poking around with him for?”

The control was gone. Not the volume, he hadn’t raised his voice exactly, but the architecture, the careful professional structure that had held the room together for an hour, simply left. What stood in its place was the Jack Larry knew from years of difficult phone calls, the Jack who pushed a colleague against a lockers and called his attorney four times at nine at night.

Karen’s expression didn’t change. Not by a single degree. “I need to understand all the relevant facts, Dr. Connor.”

“You met with him.” Not a question.

“Yes.”

“And?” The word stripped of everything but the demand inside it.

She held his gaze a moment. “He was very gracious,” she said.

Jack’s energy was filling the room.

“He’s found his footing. The transition clearly wasn’t easy, but he seems settled now. He said he left the group before it closed.” She was spitballing now. His reaction mentioning Gula was a tell. “It sounds like it was a difficult time for everyone involved.”

Jack was red. Not embarrassment or exertion. Red, the color of a blood-pressure event, up at the temples and above the beard line, the kind that arrives when the body has taken over from the mind and is doing what it does regardless of cost. His hand on the water bottle had gone rigid. His jaw was set hard enough that Larry could see the muscle working at the corner of it.

Larry said, in the measured tone of someone who has been a pressure valve for two decades and was so practiced at it that it was now reflex: “I think a short break might be useful.”

He watched Karen hear it, process it, and decide in about a second. She looked at Larry with an expression that acknowledged what he’d done without remarking on it, then at Jack with an expression that was nothing but reasonable and kind.

“Of course. These meetings take a lot out of people, and that’s completely understandable. Why don’t we take thirty minutes. There’s a small lounge at the end of the hall if you’d like some privacy.”

“That would be great,” Larry said.

She stood, smiled at them both with the same warmth she’d walked in with, and left the room.

The door closed.

Larry looked at Jack.

Jack was staring at the middle of the table. The color still high, his hand still on the water bottle, rigid, as if he’d forgotten it was there.

“Jack.”

Nothing.

“Jack. Look at me.”

Jack looked up. His eyes were still inside something and not yet out of it.

“You need to pull it together,” Larry said quietly. Not unkindly. But flatly, past the point of managing his approach. “She is going to walk back in here in thirty minutes, and you are going to be the person you were for the first forty-five minutes of this meeting. Do you understand what I’m telling you?”

Jack said nothing for a moment. Then he set the water bottle down, very deliberately, and looked off toward the window. “She went to see Gula.”

“I heard her.”

“What did he tell her?”

“Nothing, from the sound of it. Jack, who cares? What would he have to say anyway?”

“She said he was guarded.”

“Jack, Jesus. He has nothing to do with this. I don’t know what the problem is but let me tell you this.” Larry leaned forward a little. “Right now, you are your own worst problem in this room. Not her. Not Gula. You. She’s doing her job. It was a huge policy. Get a fuckin’ grip. Is that clear?”

Jack looked at him. The color had pulled back a little. Something behind his eyes was working through it, arriving at the place where the anger was still present but subordinated, filed behind the part of him that knew Larry was right.

“Clear,” he said.

They rode down without speaking and walked out into the Saturday noise of Madison Avenue.

“Look, I’m sorry,” Jack said. “It’s just a lot. All of it. The past, Ilana’s death.” He looked sincere. That was the problem, Larry thought. He looked the part.

“I get it. Don’t worry,” Larry said.

“If you don’t mind, I think I’ll just take a walk alone.”

Larry said of course. Inside he was thrilled. He never understood what severed the relationship between Jack and Gula, but what he learned up there in the conference room was that whatever happened between them was still very much alive.

Chapter Ten

Jack walked.

Not toward anything. Just away from the building, west on 56th, past the doormen and the Saturday delivery trucks and the weekend version of Midtown that was quieter and somehow more itself than the weekday one. Hands in his jacket pockets, he was talking to himself the way he did when no one was watching, not out loud exactly but close to it, the words forming and dissolving just under the threshold of sound.

Why. Why had he done that. He’d known since the letter arrived, had known in some form longer than that, that this moment was coming. That someone would look. That someone would ask about White Plains. People always asked about White Plains. He’d prepared for it. He’d sat across from Larry twice and run the sequence, the right answers, the right register, the right weight of grief at the right moments, and then he’d walked into a conference room with a woman who looked like she should be selling something wholesome and lost his composure over a name. A name. The stain of White Plains, having to shut it down, Gula - all of it.

He turned south on Fifth and passed Trump Tower, where a cluster of Asian tourists had assembled on the sidewalk, phones raised in unison toward the polished black facade and gold lettering, one selfie stick extended at an angle that took a certain commitment to optimism. Jack moved through them without slowing and they parted around him without looking up.

He kept walking. The Ativan was in his breast pocket. He fished it out, broke it in half between thumbnail and finger, put the larger piece in his mouth, chewed, swallowed. It tasted like nothing to him now. Anyone else would have made a face.

He kept walking.

Cope and Singer. He turned the names over. She’d spoken to them. Not that it mattered, he thought, because neither of them had said anything that mattered, because neither of them could. Cope had nothing to gain and everything to lose, same as Singer. Singer especially. The butcher, they’d called her, not to her face but to each other, with the dark affection of people who’ve watched someone operate without inhibition and decided pretending they didn’t see it was the best available response. She was a producer. Whatever Singer had told this woman would have been the same smooth nothing Jack himself had delivered. Differences of opinion. Better opportunities. The group had run its course. They’d all rehearsed it until it had no edges left.

So that wasn’t it. That wasn’t what was eating him. What her questions had actually stirred was the years themselves. He didn’t like to go back there, and his mind went anyway, the way a tongue goes to a cracked tooth. The lawyers in those last months telling them what to say on the phone and what never to say on any phone. The sedan he was sure he’d seen twice in one week. The cold that came over a room when the word federal was used in it, even hypothetically, even by counsel paid to use it. Nothing had ever come. No charges, no letter with his name on it, nothing in the end but the bank note, paid and buried. But the fear had moved in during those months and never quite given up the lease, and the woman upstairs with the legal pad had just walked past every room in his life and stopped, casually, at that door.

And the cost of it. He had built White Plains. The conferences, the ribbon cuttings, the dinners where the hospital president knew his favorite wine. And he’d been put out of it like a tenant who missed four months rent. That was the truth he had never said out loud to anyone: the group had not run its course; it had been taken down around him and he’d been swept out with the rest. Ilana had been furious. Not frightened. Furious, which was worse. He’d told her the truth as he needed it to be, Cope and Singer and their surgeries, operations that hadn’t needed doing, backs opened for the billing, and because they all did spine together his cases sat in the same files and looked like their cases to anyone who came reviewing. Roped in. Painted with their brush. She’d listened and nodded and said she believed him. He’d spent the rest of the marriage wondering whether she did.

He crossed 53rd without looking at the light and thought about Gula.

Once they’d been like brothers. That was the word that kept surfacing and the one he kept refusing, because brothers was wrong. Brothers was a thing you were given. What he and Gula had been was closer to what men share in war, the bond of two people who’d stood in the same trench through the lean early years: the investigations, the lawsuits, the nights the whole thing nearly came apart, who had each watched the other do what the situation required and never mentioned it after. You didn’t love a man like that, exactly. You were welded to him. And he’d cut the weld anyway. Classic chess mistake, gone hard and fast for the queen and left his own position exposed. He’d listened to Singer and Cope, who had skin in the game, who had licenses to protect, and made their problem his decision.

That was the part with teeth in it. Because when the sky actually started coming down, in those last months, the person he’d have gone to was Gula. That had been the arrangement of his whole adult life without his ever naming it: Jack broke things and stood in front of rooms, and Gula counted, and arranged, and made problems be over. Gula could probably have fixed it. Could have managed the wind-down, the bank, the partners, the lawyers, could have walked them all out of the building in good order the way he’d walked them through everything for eighteen years. Instead Jack had fired the fire department and stood in the yard watching the house burn. And what was Gula now? Not a friend. Not a partner. His what? He tried the word enemy and it didn’t fit and didn’t not fit, and the not knowing was its own category of fear.

Gula still had things to protect. Just fewer of them than Jack did, which was the arithmetic that made him dangerous. Dangerous was too strong, he corrected himself. Gula had enough to lose. He’d tow the line. But still. She’d said guarded. Not hostile, not forthcoming. Guarded.

Breathe, he told himself. He could hear Ilana saying it. You’re making a thing where there isn’t one. He stopped a moment outside a hotel entrance and felt, briefly and without invitation, something that was not quite grief and not quite its absence but somewhere in the complicated country between.

He took a breath. Then another. Twenty minutes, he told himself. Then go back.

He was calmer when he walked back into the conference room, which Karen noticed before he’d fully cleared the doorway. The color was gone. He moved differently, not relaxed, but returned to a version of himself that was more deliberate, more managed, the storm having passed through and left something quieter behind it.

He came to his chair and stayed standing a moment.

“I want to apologize,” he said, looking straight at her. “That was unprofessional. I don’t have an excuse for it.”

“Dr. Connor, please.” Karen shook her head slightly. “You’ve been through an enormous amount. A meeting like this on top of everything else is a lot to ask of anyone.” She paused. “I should have flagged earlier that I’d spoken with former colleagues. That’s on me.”

She noted, as she said it, that his mouth was dry, and that his pupils had shifted in the way she’d learned to read over six years across tables from people. He’d taken something during the break. The tells were always the tells.

He sat. “Those years, when the group dissolved, it wasn’t just a business matter. It put me, Ilana, and Maya through a lot. More than I’ve talked about with most people.” He paused. “Sitting here going over it brings Ilana back. Makes it fresh again.” He shook his head. “Not an excuse. Just an explanation.”

“You don’t need to explain anything,” she said warmly.

“Surgeons,” Jack said. “Our control issues. Occupational hazard.”

“Turf and scalpel,” she said. “I get it.”

Across the table Larry’s shoulders came down and his face opened, a man watching weather clear, relief. She read it and filed it. Twenty years of these storms, that look said. Twenty years of waiting them out.

She picked up the legal pad, flipped a page, set it back down. Her phone, face-down on the table, buzzed once. She picked it up without looking at the screen, pressed the side button to silence it, set it back down. She’d asked the receptionist to call it at the forty-minute mark. The phone, the pad, the small redirect, none of it meant anything. It meant everything. People relaxed by her fake distraction. It was the oldest move and it still worked every time.

“Right,” she said, looking back at the pad with the organized air of someone picking up a thread. “So. Finances.”

Jack’s shoulders dropped a fraction. This wasn’t where they’d left it, and Jack knew it, and the small involuntary release told Karen what she needed to know about what he’d been bracing for on the walk back.

“I want to say first,” she said, “that everything I’ve looked at on that front is clean. Genuinely. Both yours and Ilana’s.” She said it like someone reporting good news, which it was, partially. “I hope that’s some comfort.”

“It is,” Jack said.

“I do want to be transparent about what I looked at. I apologize for the intrusion, it’s unavoidable on a claim this size.” She held his eyes. “Ilana’s retirement vehicles, the pension, the 401K, the 403B, the various accounts, total around five million. A hundred percent of that goes to a trust for Maya.” She paused. “I assume you knew about that arrangement.”

Jack nodded. “That was our plan. If something happened to me, Ilana would manage everything. But we both felt her retirement assets should go directly to Maya if something happened to her. After all,” he said, “she’s going to get everything eventually.”

“Of course.” She tilted her head, a thought apparently arriving. “Honestly, if I had a daughter...” She let it go, smiled in a way that suggested the thought was personal and she wasn’t going to finish it. “Very thoughtful.”

She moved through the investments efficiently. The ski house in Vermont. The lake house in the Adirondacks. A few questions about the accounts, the overall structure.

“The Vermont place, do you use it much?” she asked, casual, a person making conversation rather than building a record.

“We did. Less so lately. It’s on the market.”

“Of course.” A small note. “And the Adirondacks property?”

“Holding onto that one.” He paused. “For now.”

She nodded and wrote and let the room go on with its gradual return to level. Jack was controlled, appropriate, doing everything right.

She flipped back through the pad with the distracted air of someone checking her work. Then stopped, and looked up with the mild, apologetic expression of someone who’s nearly overlooked something minor.

“Oh, sorry. I had a note to come back to this.” She looked at the page. “Dr. Gula.”

This time Jack’s face didn’t move. His hands, resting on the table with the loose ease of successfully reconstructed composure, went very slightly still.

He put on a smile. It arrived a half-second late. “What about him?”

“When I met with him,” Karen said, her voice carrying nothing but the mild interest of someone working a checklist, “he mentioned a situation toward the end of the group’s life. A revolving credit line with Bank of America. The personal guarantees were renegotiated. He said it was the one thing that really stayed with him.” She looked at the pad. “He mentioned the US Attorney’s office had been in contact.” This was a lie, built and placed for the sole purpose of watching what his face did with it.

Jack said nothing. He held her eyes.

“I did pull that thread,” she went on, “just to be thorough. And I can see it was resolved. Paid in full, case closed.” She set the pen down. “I just wanted to ask you directly. That was simply the group disbanding? Things falling through the cracks in a complicated wind-down?”

The room held very still.

Jack cleared his throat. “Yeah.” Measured. Slightly weary. “Just a lot to deal with. A lot of moving parts when the group split. Payment slipped through the cracks.” He held her eyes. “As you said. Paid in full.”

Jack wondered how she knew. Could Gula have known? It was an honest mistake. No one really knew the business after Gula was fired. That one little error, one of the truly honest mistakes had caused so many problems.

Karen smiled at him. Warm, finishing. “That’s what I thought,” she said. “Frankly, when Gula brought it up I figured it was more about him than anything else. You can always tell the difference between a real issue and someone nursing an old grudge.” She paused. “He struck me as someone with unresolved feelings about how things ended. We see it constantly in this business. People assume the investigator is a place to deposit old grievances. Grudges aren’t claims. I stopped collecting them years ago.”

Jack nodded. He said nothing. Inside he was boiling with rage.

“Anyway.” She set the pad aside with the brisk finality of someone closing a chapter. “I think that covers what I needed. I really do appreciate you both making the time on a weekend.”

Larry looked up. “The paperwork, you mentioned you’d have some things for Dr. Connor to sign.”

“I’ll messenger it over early in the week, after I’ve filed my report,” Karen said, with the mild apology of someone explaining a minor procedural delay.

“And the timeline on the claim itself?”

“Once the report’s filed and the paperwork’s signed, we move to processing. Shouldn’t be long.” She looked at Jack. “I know the waiting’s been difficult. I’m sorry for that.”

Jack nodded. The disappointment was there if you knew where to look, sitting just under the surface of his expression. He’d come into the room expecting to leave with something signed. He was leaving with a business card. Karen noticed and said nothing about it.

“Just routine,” she said. “I want to make sure everything’s in order before we put paper in front of anyone. Better for everyone that way.”

She opened the leather folio beside her files and produced two business cards, setting one in front of each of them. “Please don’t hesitate to reach out if anything comes up.”

Larry picked up the card and looked at it for a moment with the instinctive attention of a lawyer reading anything printed.

They stood, shook hands, and she thanked them again with the warmth she’d carried in and out of the room all day. Larry and Jack walked to the elevator in a silence that had a great deal in it, none of which was going to be said until they were somewhere private.

The elevator arrived. The doors closed.

“The meeting went fine,” Larry said. “The first part notwithstanding.”

The elevator reached the lobby. The doors opened.

“I’ll call you this week when she sends over the paperwork,” Larry said.

“Thanks, Larry,” Jack said sincerely.

“You want a ride back to your hotel?”

“No, I think I’ll walk. I’m spending another night. The walk will do me good.”

Jack turned right and Larry went left.

As Larry walked towards the parking garage he thought about the three hours that had just passed, the legal pad, the question about the bank note delivered like a woman who already knew the answer and was simply giving the other person the courtesy of saying it themselves.

He thought she was never closing this file.

Chapter Eleven

The room was dark, but he knew it was daytime. The blackout shades had done their job with the thoroughness of a thing built for people who need to not know what time it is, and through them the city was entirely absent, no light, no noise, the room sealed against the morning in a way that felt less like sleep than like suspension. He lay a moment without moving, taking inventory of himself the way you do when you’re not sure what the night has left behind.

He got up and went to the bathroom.

The light was aggressive. He squinted at himself in the mirror, the beard still neat, its own small loyalty in the chaos of the morning, and opened the medicine kit he kept in his overnight bag. Two Ativan. He tapped them into his palm, looked at them a moment, took both. He needed the edge off. He needed the edge significantly off.

He opened the minibar. The two small Grey Goose bottles were gone, he had a clear memory of that much at least, and the tequila was what remained. A small bottle of Don Julio. He cracked it, drank it straight in two swallows, set the empty on the shelf, and went back to bed. He pulled the covers to his chin and lay in the merciful cold of the room, which he’d had the good sense to arrange before the evening began, the AC at its maximum, the room now the temperature of a place where sleep is the only reasonable thing to do.

He slept.

The phone rang at eleven-thirty. The front desk, with the courtesy of hotels that charge enough to make courtesy feel like a service rather than a performance.

“Dr. Connor, I’m sorry to disturb you. I wanted to check whether you’d be needing a late checkout, or”

“Another night,” he said.

“Of course. Shall I…”

He hung up.

He slept until three-thirty.

When he woke the second time it was different. The Ativan had done its work and the tequila had followed, and what was on the far side of all of it was not exactly rest but something that passed for it, the body having been given no say in the matter. He lay on his back and looked at the ceiling. Then he hit the remote and the blackout shade rose with the silent precision of a mechanism engineered to feel like a small luxury, which it was, the afternoon light coming in gray and flat over the midtown roofline.

He clicked on the television, past the hotel station with its rolling lobby footage, to the news. The anchor was saying something about something. He wasn’t listening. He needed the noise in the room, the human frequency of it, the sense that the world was still conducting its business on the other side of the glass.

He called room service.

“Good afternoon, Dr. Connor.” They pretended to know him.

“Eggs Benedict. Bloody Mary.”

“Of course. Anything else for you today?”

“That’s everything.”

He hung up, went into the bathroom, started the shower, and stood under the hot water and let the day assemble itself in order, a process that took patience and some excavation.

He thought about the day before, reconstructing it. The walk down Fifth after the meeting, the almost-affection he’d let himself feel for Gula, the old loyalty, whatever it had been. It hadn’t survived the afternoon. Because under the affection, where he didn’t go, was the wound itself. Gula had known him. All of him. The parts he showed no one, the parts that had no other witness, and the man holding all of it had been sent away by Jack’s own hand, and the loss had hurt in a way he’d never once said out loud and didn’t say now, even alone, even to the tile. What he let himself feel instead was the heat. It came up the way it always came up, fast and total, the vessel at his temple finding its pulse, his palms flat against the shower wall. Gula had forced his hand. And Gula, who knew his temper better than anyone alive, who’d watched it blow through rooms for eighteen years and knew exactly how much of it was weather, could have come back. Could have picked up the phone a week later, a month later, and let Jack walk it back the way Gula had let him walk back a hundred things. He never did. He’d taken the firing like a verdict instead of a temper, and let it stand, and that, Jack had decided long ago, was a choice. Gula knew too much and played the wounded party. Jack stood in the hot water with his jaw set hard enough to ache and understood that if Gula had been in the room at that moment he could not have answered for what his hands would do. By Saturday evening the heat had cooled into something more useful, and he’d carried it down to the bar and built the case drink by drink.

The bar. After the meeting, after the walk, after Larry had said his piece and they’d gone separate ways on Madison without making plans to speak again, both of them understanding that the next conversation would come when there was something to say, he remembered going back to the hotel, showering, changing, going down to the bar. He’d sat at the Mark Bar and had a drink and called Nicola from his phone, deliberately, the right decision, and she’d arrived within the hour with a small amount of MDMA and a bottle of Veuve she produced from her bag, easy, a woman who understood the nature of the service she was providing.

He’d done it only a few times before. He liked it better than coke for this. The coke sharpened things, made him faster and more himself, and more himself was not always what the situation called for. The MDMA did the opposite. Smoothed the edges, made the room larger, produced in him a warmth and a patience he didn’t naturally possess and that, on a night spent with a woman he was paying to be there, felt like the most honest version of what the evening could be. Made him nicer. He’d felt, for reasons he couldn’t fully account for, the need to be nice. The meeting. The day. The whole accumulated weight of Karen Callahan’s three manila files and her Yale law degree and the question about the bank note delivered in the tone of a woman who already knew the answer.

They’d fucked for hours, the MDMA’s other contribution, which he appreciated on its own terms. He had a vague memory of Nicola leaving, the door, the quiet click of it, the stillness of a room that has just become empty, and of taking the Ambien at some point after that, the bottle sitting uncapped on the nightstand this morning the only evidence of the decision. He hadn’t been unconscious exactly. The MDMA produced in him a state less like sleep than like being at a great and pleasant distance from himself, ten million miles off, looking back at the room and everything in it with the benevolent detachment of someone who has decided the day is not for him. Which was, he thought now, under the hot water, exactly right. Yesterday had not been for him. It had been for Karen Callahan and Larry McGuire and the paperwork coming in the mail. Today was for him. He was allowed today.

Larry was right. He stood there and let the water run over his shoulders and thought about it with the clarity that hot showers and Ativan produce together, and decided to believe the reasonable interpretation, because the reasonable interpretation was the only one he could afford. The meeting had been normal. The claim was normal. Seven million dollars was a number that required scrutiny, and scrutiny had been applied, and now it was over. He was owed the policy. The money was his. It had been Ilana’s money and now it was his and nothing in any room he’d sat in yesterday changed that fact. Fuck this Karen woman. Pleasant, disarming, Yale Law, and ultimately just a person with a legal pad trying to close a file. That was all. That was what this was.

He got out of the shower.

The towels were hot from the warming rack, a detail he noticed each time and each time took as full justification for what the Mark cost, a number he’d stopped looking at because the looking served no purpose. He pulled on the heavy robe and stood at the window a moment, the afternoon light flat and gray on the avenue below, the Sunday traffic moving at its Sunday pace, and felt the Ativan settling into the middle of his chest with the reliable warmth of a thing that knows its job.

The room bell sounded. Room service set the cart beside the small table near the window, the Bloody Mary under its paper cap, the eggs under a silver dome. Jack signed the check, added twenty percent, told the man to leave things as they were, and then he was alone with his eggs and the television and the gray Sunday afternoon, the city reaching him as less sound than the suggestion of sound, present but distant, like something happening in another room.

He found the Bills game on the third click.

The eggs were not hot. They were never hot with room service, a fact of physics and logistics he’d accepted years ago and periodically forgot and was periodically reminded of. He ate them anyway, working through the Hollandaise with the mild resignation of someone who has learned to adjust his expectations to the available conditions, and sipped the Bloody Mary through its long straw and watched the game and felt his shoulders come down from wherever they’d been for the past twenty-four hours.

He’d have a glass of wine with dinner and call it a night. Tomorrow was Monday, late OR block, which on any normal Monday would have irritated him, the late start meant leaving after most of the staff, a long evening, not home until nine or ten. Today he felt something close to gratitude for it. The operating room was the one place in his life where everything else went irrelevant. The room, the patient, the procedure. That was all there was. He needed that tomorrow. He was glad it was there.

His thoughts drifted off with the pleasantness of an afternoon when there’s nowhere to be and nothing required, the game on the television, the Bloody Mary cold and well made, the room still mercifully cool. He was here. He was fed. He was warm enough and medicated enough and the papers were coming in the mail and it would all be over soon.

He did not know, sitting there in the thick robe with the Bills down by four in the third quarter, that weeks later, scrolling through his sent folder for a message to his realtor about listing the house, he’d find an email he had no memory of sending. An email to Steven Gula, written in the blacked-out hours after Nicola left, when the drugs and the booze had amplified everything and the controls had come off. He didn’t know what was in it.

He sipped his Bloody Mary.

He watched the game.

He was confident and relaxed.

©2026 All Rights Reserved | Joshua D. Powell | josh@thepowellhousepress.com